PDA

View Full Version : Trade proposal thrown at me

PantherPaul
10-11-07, 10:40 AM
Who gets the best end of this

Kitna
Bo Schift (Tenn TE)
Ronald Curry (Raider receiver)

FOR

Matt Scaub
Dallas Clark
Brandon Marshall (Denver WR)
MikeNinerHunt
10-11-07, 12:29 PM
mediocrity for medicrity, who cares?
Collin
10-11-07, 04:06 PM
Pretty much a wash, but I'd rather have the top three.
Bunky
10-12-07, 09:58 AM
i'd gladly take the bottom 3 for the top 3. while schaub/kitna may be a wash by the end of the year, kitna sure is spending a bunch of time on his back-25 sacks already!! since vince young took over, tenn te's don't mean a thing. i like curry, but marshall is just as good, imo.
Thelt
10-12-07, 02:54 PM
Clark is having a good year so far, he probably tips the trade in favor of the guy getting him.
marlinfan1
10-13-07, 12:46 AM
Clark is having a good year so far, he probably tips the trade in favor of the guy getting him.....Clark has become a legit got man. As for Kitna v. Matt, Kitna can rock but his team offense sucks, Marshall at Denver will be a Moss/Owens soon. Can Cutler give him the ball? If yes, he will get 10+ TDs, and comparing him to Ronald Curry is a joke!
Collin
10-14-07, 11:56 PM
If yes, he will get 10+ TDs, and comparing him to Ronald Curry is a joke!
Brandon Marshall has obvious physical talent, but he's the #2 receiver on a team with a run-oriented offense and an inconsistent quarterback. Meanwhile Curry is a steady but unspectacular #1 receiver on a bad team that will need to pass a lot, and has some veteran QBs throwing to him.
PantherPaul
10-15-07, 06:17 AM
I took the trade. I already have Jason Witten so Clark was just holding down a spot. I was hurting for a player this week so Curry helped With already having Roy Williams and Chad Johnson playing time was going to be tough for Marshall except for bye weeks which for me are all but done. I just valued Kitna more due to their team sucking and playing from behind. That and Mike Martz has been known to throw the ball a little.