Top 16 Active NFL QB's...

Who are your top 16? Here's mine:

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Brees
4. Rodgers
5. Luck
6. Roethlisberger
7. Wilson
8. Romo
9. Rivers
10. Stafford
11. Smith
12. Ryan
13. Dalton
14. Kaepernick
15. Foles
16. Newton

 

I stopped reading when I saw Brady at #1.

 

You could take a group of practice squad players and TB would figure out a way to win w/ them. Poor rationale.

 

Uh, no. Not anymore anyway. There's a reason why New England and suddenly starting running the ball so much.


FWIW, the top 10 of your list isn't totally god awful, but I would switch Brady with Rodgers, and perhaps even Wilson with Brady. It's not meant to be a lifetime achievement list. I would also swap Kaepernick or Cam with Stafford.

 

We can disagree. It's cool, but I'd like to see your top 16...

 

1. Rodgers
2. Manning
3. Brees
4. Wilson
5. Brady
6. Luck
7. Roethlisberger
8. Kaepernick
9. Rivers
10. Newton
11. Ryan
12. Romo


That's my top 12. I don't think the space between 13 and 20 is even worth distinguishing.

 

That's a solid 12. How long before Luck is at the top of the list? Dude is damn near carry the Colts on his own.

 

He'll be one of the top 3 eventually. And he does pretty much carry that team. Panther fans hate it, but he's in another league from Cam.

 

a coupla years when he gets even better and manning, rogers and brees start declining. wilson may even get better and surpass them as well while they are still playing, but who knows. Kaep and Newton could surpass them in a few years if they get better and they decline some as well. Team play and surrounding talent are huge. Just think if the colts had a great team and he had talent around him.

but newton better work on his game a lot better soon or he will get passed by others. he has the potential to rise and be top 3-5, but i dunno. also depend upon who comes into the league over then next few years as well.

 

Wow, really? Handing off to Jamaal Charles is the 11th best QB, not Alex Smith. I thought that with the years you had to observe this you would see he's not anything special.